Iraq Revenue Watch

Revenue Watch Institute

Reports & Briefings

Key Documents

Links

 
   
 
   

Open Society Institute

EurasiaNet

Publish What You Pay

   

KEEPING SECRETS: AMERICA AND IRAQ'S PUBLIC FINANCES
A New Report from the Open Society Institute
October 2003

Read the full report PDF file

NEW YORK, October 14-Iraq's public finances fall short of international standards of accountability, says a report released today by the Iraq Revenue Watch project of the Open Society Institute.

Keeping Secrets: America and Iraq's Public Finances, released on the eve of an international donors' conference for Iraq in Madrid, calls for greater transparency in the management of the Development Fund for Iraq (DFI), the central repository for Iraqi revenues. The Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) has delayed the establishment of a crucial oversight body and refused to disclose basic information about large purchase contracts and DFI expenditures, the report says.

The Iraqi public, as well as members of the United Nations Security Council, which mandated the creation of the DFI, have been left in the dark about how the Fund works.

Further, the DFI fails to serve Iraqi interests. "Bidding processes for big reconstruction contracts take place behind closed doors, excluding Iraqi businesses that are unable to compete with multinational corporations," said Isam al Khafaji, director of Iraq Revenue Watch.

Oversight of the DFI is also inadequate, the report contends. The UN-mandated International Advisory and Monitoring Board, which is supposed to report back to the Security Council and ensure that DFI funds are properly used, has yet to be established. Instead, a separate CPA-created entity, the Program Review Board, votes on expenditures and has just one Iraqi member with voting privileges. This Board is often slow to publicize minutes from its biweekly meetings, and what minutes are produced lack essential information, such as the DFI's current balance.

The Coalition Provisional Authority's failure to disclose financial information threatens to jeopardize contributions from other donors. There is now talk among international actors about creating a separate Iraqi reconstruction fund for non-U.S. donations, a move that would only complicate matters for a future interim Iraqi administration.

The report calls on the Coalition Provisional Authority to reverse these trends and offers a set of recommendations, including increased Iraqi involvement in the DFI, the establishment of the International Advisory and Monitoring Board, and better public access to information.

"With the United States increasingly isolated from other donor countries, it must work to regain the confidence of the international community and the Iraqi people," said al Khafaji.

"An important step in that direction is improving the management of Iraq's public finances. That would also be key to bringing about stability."

Read the full report PDF file

 

   
 

CSIS: Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq
December 2007 report from the Center for Strategic & International Studies assessing the U.S. Defense Departments latest report on Iraq. The CSIS report cites "strong indicators that the glass has gone from one that was mostly empty to one that is at least half full," but adds that the military assessment "scarcely describes a stable or secure Iraq and it indicates that the Iraq War still presents a high risk of failure."

IMF Review (August, 2007) PDF file
Report on Iraq’s economic situation, the effects of deteriorations in security, and progress on strengthening macroeconomic and structural reforms, based on IMF meetings with Iraqi officials and analysis by the IMF staff and Executive Board.

 

archive >

 
 

Development Fund for Iraq: Summary of 2007 Audit PDF file
Ernst & Young's summary of findings for the period ending December 31, 2006, from the International Advisory and Monitoring Board for Iraq (IAMB).

Smuggling of Crude Petroleum and Products (In Arabic) PDF file
2006
The second transparency report produced by the inspector general of Iraq's ministry of oil, describing corruption in the oil sector, and in particular the multi-billion dollar smuggling of crude petroleum and refined products.

 

archive >